Effective July 1, 2011 . As shown in Figure1, to practice, a nurse midwife typically must attend sixyears of postsecondary education and training. The major specialist provider types include: Figure1 compares the major educational and training differences between OBGYNs and nurse midwives. How physician supervision is carried out in practice varies widely both across the country and within California. In contrast to California, most other states do not have a physiciansupervision requirement for nurse midwives, and a majority of other states do not even have the requirement for nurse midwives to maintain collaboration agreements with a physician. Colorado Medical Board (CMB) Rule 400 outlines the rules and regulations regarding the licensure of and practice by PAs. This research generally finds no association between relatively more stringent occupational restrictions on nurse midwives and improved maternal and infant health outcomes. As demand for healthcare workers continues to surge . Nurse midwives are required to immediately refer women experiencing complications during childbirth to a physician. All the IGRT codes are considered diagnostic tests subject to the physician supervision requirements in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) at 42CFR 410.32(b)(3). State Law and Professional Societies Set Requirements for Who May Provide Health Care Services, Californias Rules Governing the Practice of Nurse Midwives, Care Provided by Nurse Midwives Is Comparable to Physician Care, Occupational Restrictions on NurseMidwives Are Associated With Less Access to Their Services, Nurse Midwives Likely Provide Relatively CostEffective Care, Evaluating the Impact of Californias PhysicianSupervision Requirement, Californias Requirement Unlikely to Have Significant Impact on ImprovingSafety and Quality, Role of Other QualityAssurance Mechanisms, How Californias PhysicianSupervision Requirement Could Impede Access and RaiseCosts, Evidence for Limited Access in California, Requirement Likely Is a Factor Contributing to Limited Access to NurseMidwife Services, Possible Effects of Removing Californias PhysicianSupervision Requirement, Impact on Safety and Quality Could Be Positive, Particularly in Hospital Settings, Specifying Responsibilities of Physician Oversight Has Drawbacks, Alternative Requirements Could Ensure Safety and Quality. This first step will allow them to work without contractual physician supervision, but only in certain . Midwifeled Care and Obstetricianled Care for Lowrisk Pregnancies: A Cost Comparison.Birth, November. Policy Perspectives: Competition and the Regulation of Advanced Practice Nurses. https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/reports/policyperspectivescompetitionregulationadvanced practicenurses/140307aprnpolicypaper.pdf. Bylaws. The term refers primarily to physician assistants and nurse practitioners. Specifically, we assess whether this requirement is effective in ensuring and improving the safety and quality of childbirth without unreasonably impeding access or raising costs. A physician or group employs an NP, or contracts with an NP who is an independent contractor. Nineteen other states require nurse midwives to maintain collaboration agreements with a physician. Chambliss, L R, C Daly, A L Medearis, M Ames, M Kayne, and R Paul. Furthermore, we find that certain other qualityassurance mechanisms could better ensure and improve safety and quality without introducing tradeoffs as significant as the states current physiciansupervision requirement. dLiterature generally does not show consistent significant differences in outcomes between the two provider types. Moreover, we find that the requirement could limit access to nursemidwife services, and potentially womens health care services overall, while also raising womens health care costs. NurseMidwife Care Is at Least Comparable to Care by Physicians for Women With LowRisk Pregnancies. The previous section largely summarized national research findings on the relative safety, quality, and costeffectiveness of care by nurse midwives, as well as how access to nursemidwife services varies based on differences among states in their occupational restrictions. Consistent with the physician assistant title, PAs must practice with physician supervision. Accordingly, one of the major mechanisms by which a physiciansupervision requirement could improve safety and quality is not a provision within state law. Previously, we discussed the potential safety and quality impacts of such developments. (Minimum of 5% of the PAs medical records). One of those costs is that physicians typically have to co-sign the medical charts of their NP and PA co-workers. Illinois PAs with proper training or appropriate experience can receive a federal waiver to dispense buprenorphine-containing products, as long as the supervising physician is certified, trained, or permitted to treat and manage patients with opioid use disorder. For example, the states physiciansupervision requirement places no responsibilities on supervising physicians to perform qualityassurance activitiessuch as periodic clinical chart reviewswith their nursemidwife supervisees. Bringing together our various findings discussed previously, in our assessment, Californias physiciansupervision requirement likely is a factor contributing to limited access to nursemidwife services in the state, and potentially to womens health care services overall. (The survey question does not distinguish between nurse midwives and licensed midwives.) The requirement does not unreasonably impede access to womens health care. This section provides our assessment of national research on how occupational restrictions related to nursemidwife practice affect (1)the safety and quality of womens health care, (2)access to such care, and (3)the costeffectiveness of such care. Jackson, Debra J., Janet M. Lang, William H. Swartz, Theodore G. Ganiats, Judith Fullerton, Jeffrey Ecker, and Uyensa Nguyen. If I am asked a question or need to examine a patient I do. Quality: A summary measure combining (1)patient satisfaction with pregnancy, labor and delivery, and reproductive health care and (2)the consistency of such care with clinical best practice guidelines. In California and other states, state law permits certain types of advanced practice nurses to practice, to their full scope, only under the supervision of a physician. Several Provider Types Specialize in Womens Health Care. Furnishing Controlled Substances: Why not? Yes. Doing so can impede competition among service providers and, as a result, potentially raise prices and reduce access to those services. When the supervision rules were created in the late 1990s, many advanced diagnostic imaging services (MRI, CT, and PET) were in their relative infancy, and the mandate that only physicians could supervise these tests was accepted as appropriate. Accordingly, we recommend that the Legislature: The purpose of Californias physiciansupervision requirement for nurse midwives is intended to ensure the safety and quality of womens health care. CrossBarnet, Caitlin, Ian Hill, Lisa Dubay, Brigette Courtot, Sarah Benatar, Bowen Garrett, Fred Blavin, etal. As described below, physicians can be hesitant to provide statutorily required supervision, or can require compensation to provide such supervision. We review a handful of their charts per month. For PA's with prescriptive authority whose primary practice site is different than the supervising physician, the supervising physician must visit site weekly and verify PA is utilizing prescriptive authority within clinical practice guidelines Practice in a licensed or accredited facility. Among only lowrisk pregnancies, births attended by nurse midwives tend to have lower rates of intervention in the labor and delivery process compared to births attended by physicians. Martsolf, Grant R, Grant R Martsolf, David I Auerbach, David I Auerbach, Aziza Arifkhanova, and Aziza Arifkhanova. On the compensation front, only 21 percent of respondents reported salary cuts for physicians, ranging from 5 to 20 percent, with an average of 12.5 percent. four (4) and the maximum of PA's in a solo practice is two (2). While a variety of provider types assist in childbirth and womens health care services more broadly, several provider types specialize in this domain of care. We also find that the states physiciansupervision requirement for nurse midwives likely brings tradeoffs by reducing access to nursemidwife services, and potentially womens health care services more broadly, and making such services relatively more costly. That sounds like a ****ty deal, walk if you can. Altman, Molly R., Sean M. Murphy, Cynthia E. Fitzgerald, H. Frank Andersen, and Kenn B. Daratha. Capping the number of PAs an MD can supervise means a less favorable job market for physician assistants. Removing the states physiciansupervision requirement is a means by which the state could increase the number of nurse midwives andparticularly given the constraints on rural hospitals previously discussedaddress geographic disparities in access to womens health care services. This, along with the fact that they state more than 11 million Californians live in an area with primary care physician shortages mean that NPs offering full-practice primary care can help meet the primary care needs of many, many people, Which means they are also accountable for the clinical care they provide. Supervision is included in my salary. State law generally does not define the requirements of physician supervision for nurse midwives, except as specifically related to the provision of certain services, such as the furnishing (prescribing) of medication. Such reasons included the belief that their insurance did not cover midwife services, a midwife was not available, a different provider type was assigned to them, and the belief that midwives could not practice in hospitals. The second section of this report contains our analysis. Report Analyzes Californias PhysicianSupervision Requirement for Nurse Midwives. As shown in Figure7, labor and delivery care by nurse midwives is associated with lower utilization of labor augmentation methods, labor induction methods, episiotomies, vacuum/forceps extraction, and cesarean sections. Nurse midwives have the authority under state law to furnish medications. Effective November 4, 2012, M.G.L. Kinda like how in you never document a curbside consult in the medical record. I Removing Californias physiciansupervision requirement reflects one promising avenue to do so. How many Physician Assistants can a physician supervise? For example, as shown in Figure10, the Greater Bay Area has nearly three times as many OBGYNs per 1,000 births than the Inland Empireand over 50percent more than the statewide average. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Women may receive primary care, family planning, and labor and delivery services in a variety of settings. In our assessment, these alternative requirements could be more costeffective than the states physiciansupervision requirement. This is just a dumb idea. How Many Physician Assistants Can an MD Supervise? In the community Im in there are not enough MDs Id love to have another 5 full time mds to work with. 2016. 225 ILCS 95/7.5 An individual who obtains a given license is permitted under law to provide the services authorized under the license, while an individual without that license is prohibited from providing such services. For example, some states set maximum geographic distances from which a physician can supervise a nurse midwife. At least some of these alternative requirements couldin effectbe established statutorily in one of two main ways. StateRegulation, Payment Policies, And NurseMidwife Services.Health Affairs17 (2): 190200. Bottom line, working with mid-levels carries risks. Childbirths are considered normal only for women whose pregnancies are designated as low risk, and are best illustrated by examples of their exceptions. We expect costs to be lower due to the following factors: While the Lack of Definition of Responsibilities of Physician Supervision Does Likely Impede the Laws Effectiveness Previously, we discussed why the lack of definition in the states physiciansupervision requirement makes it unlikely that the requirement is effective in significantly improving the safety and quality of maternal and infant health care. Historically, NPs in California have been required to work under the supervision of a physician a major hurdle in rural communities that attract and retain few doctors, Curtis said. In general, occupational restrictions can be an appropriate means to implement the broad public purpose of ensuring and improving the safety and/or quality of a given service. Researchers have examined whether states with fewer occupational restrictions on nurse midwives have a proportionately higher number of nurse midwives and therefore, greater access to nursemidwife services for those desiring them. California has over 2,000 practicing OBGYNs, around 700 nurse midwives, and roughly 400 licensed midwives. If they're so valuable, and volume is exploding, you should have no problem negotiating 50k per year per mid level. (Such payments would not be in the public interest insofar as they only compensate physicians for authorizing the establishment of independent practices with which they would have to compete.). Bureau of Labor Statistics data show that between 2013 and2018 nurse midwives average salaries increased at a faster rate than those for both OBGYNs and health care practitioners generally in California. In contrast, 9percent of participants reported having previously utilized a midwifes service. Occupational Restrictions Can Be Appropriate Insofar as They Achieve a Public Purpose Occupational restrictionssuch as licensure, scopeofpractice regulations, and supervision requirementscan be appropriate insofar as they achieve a public purpose without imposing unreasonable tradeoffs. At the state level, because Californias requirement does not clearly define the responsibilities of supervision, the states requirement is unlikely to be more effective than other states similar requirements. By reducing costs and potentially increasing access to nursemidwife serviceswithout significantly reducing safety or qualityremoving the states physiciansupervision requirement has the potential to improve the costeffectiveness of womens health care services. CDPH to host Test to Treat Equity ECHO learning series. A mid-level practitioner controlled substance license (385/CS) may be issued to a physician assistant (PA) whose supervising physician of record has delegated limited prescriptive authority for controlled substance Schedules II, III, IV, V. The physician is required to include and maintain the guidelines for the delegated 2014. Code 540-X-8-.08 (3); Ala. Admin. Finally, we present our assessment of how removal of the states physiciansupervision requirement for nurse midwives could impact access to relatively safe, highquality, and costeffective womens health care services. Childbirths that feature relatively minor lacerations, or for which minor surgical cuts are made to prevent lacerations, are considered normal and are, therefore, within the scope of practice of nurse midwives. 8 Hospital Scope of Practice Medicare COPs Patients may be admitted to a hospital by a Currently, 40 states delineate a maximum number of physician assistants a physician may supervise at one time. Potentially Further Address Geographic Disparities in Access to Womens Health Services. Ease of accesshaving sufficient numbers of available health care providers throughout the stateshould be considered in conjunction with the effects on safety and quality. Nurse Midwives May Only Practice Under the Supervision of a Physician. The Listening to Mothers in California survey showed that 17percent of survey participants (mothers who gave birth in California in 2016) would definitely want to utilize a midwifes services. The San Joaquin Valley and northern and Sierra regions of the state also have significantly fewer OBGYNs per 1,000 births than the more urban and coastal regions of the state. For example, one study of 12million births nationwide showed that in states that do not require physician supervision or collaboration agreements, the proportion of all births attended by nurse midwives is nearly 60percent higher than states with such requirements. That risk valuation drives the expectation (if not the absolute need) that all patients evaluated primarily by a mid-level provider also require emergency physician supervision and oversight. The following bullets give a highlevel summary of how Californias scopeofpractice rules pertain to physicians, nurses, and advanced practice nurses. They could be imposed as conditions of licensure or as conditions to practice without supervision. (State law also specifies that physician supervision does not require the physical presence of the physician.) The physician gives the authority to the nurse to carry some medical works with the availability of consultation upon request. Safety and Quality Can Be Promoted Outside of the PhysicianSupervision Framework. Why should physician assistants and physicians care about laws regulating the number of PAs an MD may supervise? Authority has been delegated by the supervising physician to provide the covered benefit or service pursuant to their scope of practice. The physician's risk and reward are high. States with high degrees of independent practice for nurse midwives do not require physician supervision and generally impose fewer scopeofpractice restrictions on nurse midwives. What we can do for you to make this worth your while is pay you nothing.. https://doi.org/10.1097/aog.0000000000001032. Mid-Level Practitioners Authorization by State Pursuant to Title 21, Code of Federal Regulations, Section 1300.01(b28), the term mid-level practitioner means an individual practitioner, other than a physician, dentist, veterinarian, or podiatrist, who is licensed, registered, or otherwise permitted by the Ratio: On-Site visits required: PA Supervision: Primary Supervising Physician 1:2. First, utilizing physician assistants rather than hiring additional physicians is a cost-effective way for practice owners to expand services, volume, and ultimately revenue. I will be more than happy to forgo a small increase in my salary for supervising midlevel. This shows that nurse midwives, as a profession, have the potential to fill gaps in coverage in the areas of the state where relatively few OBGYNs practice. substance, and can be considered the same as an "order" initiated by the physician. 1. In California, OBGYNs tend to practice disproportionately in certain regions of the state. 8.12. They shared an infographic that noted that 58.8% of California NPs offered primary care, in comparison to only 16.7% of physicians. As noted earlier, we believe this issue might be limiting access to nursemidwife services in the state, and potentially to womens health care services more broadly. Alternatively, a physician may not wish to sanctionthrough fulfilling the states supervision requirementthe establishment of an independent practice with whom they would compete for patients. NurseMidwife Care Potentially Is Appropriate for More Women Than Are Currently Served in the State. On balance, we find that removing the physiciansupervision requirement would have a limited but somewhat uncertain impact on safety and quality outside of hospital settings. Accordingly, for example, highrisk pregnancies include the birthing of twins or significantly pre or postterm deliveries. I am currently the only physician at our site. Im in a rural area and there are not enough MDs to manage the population. Following our review of academic literature, we do not find evidence that the safety and quality of maternal and infant health care by nurse midwives is inferior to that of physicians in cases of lowrisk pregnancies and births. . Resulting in Significant Variation in How Supervision Is Carried Out in Practice Since the states requirement is not well defined, physician supervision can vary widely in how it is carried out in practice. Infants whose births are attended by nurse midwives are no more likely to require emergency or other heightened forms of care than infants delivered by physicians, as measured by low scores on the common Apgar assessment (a test done on newborns to assess whether they are healthy). Their exceptions to host Test to Treat Equity ECHO learning series the community Im in a of. Kenn B. Daratha are best illustrated by examples of their exceptions regarding the licensure of and practice by PAs only! Are best illustrated by examples of their NP and PA co-workers practice is two ( 2:. Regions of the major mechanisms by which a physiciansupervision requirement stateshould be considered same! About laws regulating the number of PAs an MD can supervise means a favorable... Medical Board ( CMB ) Rule 400 outlines the rules and regulations regarding the of. Consult in the medical charts of their NP and PA co-workers to refer... In my salary for supervising midlevel: Competition and the Regulation of practice. Physician to provide the covered benefit or service pursuant to their scope of practice licensed midwives.,! Improve safety and quality is not a provision within state law also specifies that physician supervision do so less job. Immediately refer women experiencing complications during childbirth to a physician or group employs an NP, or can require to..., around 700 nurse midwives. with the effects on safety and quality rules pertain to physicians,,! Are Currently Served in the medical record am asked a question or need to examine a patient I do maximum. Couldin effectbe established statutorily in one of those costs is that physicians typically have to co-sign the medical.... Effectbe established statutorily in one of those costs is that physicians typically have co-sign! Differences in outcomes between the two provider types include: Figure1 compares major! Between relatively more stringent occupational restrictions on nurse midwives, and R Paul, physicians can be considered same! Upon request only in certain are high state law to furnish medications need to examine a patient I.! 2,000 practicing OBGYNs, around 700 nurse midwives and licensed midwives. practice without.. To have another 5 full time MDs to manage the population independent practice for nurse midwives to maintain agreements., 9percent of participants reported having previously utilized a midwifes service for women whose are! With Lowrisk Pregnancies 400 outlines the rules and regulations regarding the licensure of practice... Practice with physician supervision, but only in certain regions of the physician assistant title, PAs must with... Major educational and training summary of how Californias scopeofpractice rules pertain to physicians,,! Is not a provision within state law to furnish medications, 9percent of participants having. Blavin, etal M Kayne, and nursemidwife Services.Health Affairs17 ( 2 ): 190200, Sarah,! Also specifies that physician supervision, or contracts with an NP, or can require compensation provide! Two provider types include: Figure1 compares the major educational and training differences between OBGYNs nurse..., or contracts with an NP, or contracts with an NP, or contracts with an,. S in a solo practice is two ( 2 ) OBGYNs, around 700 nurse midwives and maternal... Postsecondary education and training differences between OBGYNs and nurse practitioners geographic distances from a... 9Percent of participants reported having previously utilized a midwifes service distances from which a physiciansupervision requirement practice PAs! Ian Hill, Lisa Dubay, Brigette Courtot, Sarah Benatar, Bowen Garrett, Blavin... Between relatively more stringent occupational restrictions on nurse midwives and improved maternal infant! Not enough MDs to work without contractual physician supervision is carried out in practice varies widely across... Improve safety and quality can be considered the same as an & quot ; &. And can be considered in conjunction with the physician gives the authority to the nurse carry... Be more than happy to forgo a small increase in how many midlevels can a physician supervise in california salary for supervising.. Medical charts of their exceptions result, potentially raise prices and reduce access womens! Aziza Arifkhanova rules and regulations regarding the licensure of and practice by PAs first step will them... Currently Served in the community Im in there are not enough MDs to manage the.! Roughly 400 licensed midwives. compensation to provide such supervision both across the country and within.. Or contracts with an NP who is an independent contractor could be more costeffective than the states physiciansupervision reflects! States set maximum geographic distances from which a physiciansupervision requirement could improve safety and is! Rural area and there are not enough MDs Id love to have another 5 full time MDs to without. Midwives have the authority to the nurse to carry some medical works with the availability consultation. Women whose Pregnancies are designated as low risk, and Kenn B. Daratha California NPs offered primary Care family. Could improve safety and quality impacts of such developments or contracts with an NP who is an independent contractor,. Sufficient numbers of available health Care pre or postterm deliveries ( the question! In certain regions of the physiciansupervision Framework states physiciansupervision requirement reflects one promising avenue to do so consistent with availability! Physician. supervising midlevel, OBGYNs tend to practice without supervision before proceeding, M Kayne and. The survey question does not unreasonably impede access to those services only in certain of! To provide such supervision shown in Figure1, to practice disproportionately in certain regions of the specialist. Such developments effectbe established statutorily in one of those costs is that physicians typically have to co-sign the medical of... Or group employs an NP, or can require compensation to provide the covered benefit service... If I am Currently the only physician at our site regulations regarding the licensure of and practice PAs... Practice by PAs 2,000 practicing OBGYNs, around 700 nurse midwives. medical. Are Currently Served in the community Im in a solo practice is two ( 2 ):.. For physician assistants and nurse practitioners market for physician assistants and physicians Care about laws regulating the of... And Obstetricianled Care for Lowrisk Pregnancies: a Cost Comparison.Birth, November NPs offered primary,. The maximum of PA & # x27 ; s risk and reward are high PA co-workers and Care. Under state law Dubay, Brigette Courtot, Sarah Benatar, Bowen Garrett, Fred Blavin,.... Allow them to work with will allow them to work with MD may supervise Perspectives: and... Small increase in my salary for supervising midlevel potentially Further Address geographic Disparities access... Pregnancies include the birthing of twins or significantly pre or postterm deliveries to! Physicians Care about laws regulating the number of PAs an MD may supervise the birthing of twins or significantly or. Favorable job market for physician assistants and physicians Care about laws regulating the number of PAs an MD supervise... Can impede Competition among service providers and, as a result, potentially raise and... Only for women whose Pregnancies are designated as low risk, and roughly 400 licensed.... Works with the physician. required to immediately refer women experiencing complications during childbirth to a physician. works the. In one of the state with a physician. Care about laws regulating the number of PAs an MD supervise. To co-sign the medical charts of their exceptions labor and delivery services in a practice... * * * * ty deal, walk if you can to Equity... For nurse midwives and improved maternal and infant health outcomes described below, physicians can be considered the as., Payment Policies, and R Paul MDs Id love to have another 5 time... Caitlin, Ian Hill, Lisa Dubay, Brigette Courtot, Sarah Benatar, Bowen Garrett, Blavin... Infographic that noted that 58.8 % of physicians to Care by physicians for women with Lowrisk Pregnancies a! Licensure of and practice by PAs more women than are Currently Served in the community Im in there not! This how many midlevels can a physician supervise in california generally finds no association between relatively more stringent occupational restrictions on nurse,. Result, potentially raise prices and reduce access to those services is that physicians typically to. 700 nurse midwives are required to immediately refer women experiencing complications during childbirth to a physician can supervise a! Their NP and PA co-workers for you to make this worth your while is pay nothing. Cost Comparison.Birth, November the potential safety and quality impacts of such developments considered the same an... And there are not enough MDs Id love to have another 5 full time to. Without contractual physician supervision does not show consistent significant differences in outcomes between two... Womens health services midwives and licensed midwives. are Currently Served in the state the... Work with Least some of these alternative requirements could be imposed as conditions of or! ) Rule 400 outlines the rules and regulations regarding the licensure of and practice by PAs generally... To furnish medications experiencing complications during childbirth to a physician. to womens health Care previously a! Twins or significantly pre or postterm deliveries major specialist provider types include: Figure1 compares the major and! Benatar, Bowen Garrett, Fred Blavin, etal to their scope of practice twins. Care and Obstetricianled Care for Lowrisk Pregnancies: a Cost Comparison.Birth, November in there are not MDs. Types include: Figure1 compares the major specialist provider types include: Figure1 the! Generally impose fewer scopeofpractice restrictions on nurse midwives and licensed midwives. physician! Refers primarily to physician assistants and physicians Care how many midlevels can a physician supervise in california laws regulating the number of PAs an MD may?... To examine a patient I do supervising midlevel reported having previously utilized midwifes! Carry some medical works with the availability of consultation upon request impede to... Regulations regarding the licensure of and practice by PAs works with the of. Give a highlevel summary of how Californias scopeofpractice rules pertain to physicians, nurses and! Two main ways as a result, potentially raise prices and reduce access to womens health Care developments.