22. This clarified the issue that immigration judges have authority to terminate cases under such circumstances with or without the concurrence of the DHS. What Is an Immigrant Visa Number and How Can I Get One? Family-Based Petitions and Adjustment of Status. 239.2(a)(7) (2018) to dismiss removal proceedings upon finding that it is an abuse of the asylum process for an alien to file a meritless asylum application with the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) for the sole purpose of pursuing cancellation . Write down any dates the judge gives you. At the initial hearing, youll spend a few minutes in front of the immigration judge. This is called an affidavit of support. Then, youll be asked to take the stand. They will look for holes in DHS case and explain any defenses you have to the judge. (2) Immigration judges may dismiss or terminate removal proceedings only under the circumstances expressly identified in the regulations, see8 C.F.R. Send your application to one of the special mailing addresses . A motion to terminate may be filed at any point during a removal proceeding, but it is recommended that it be filed before the respondent has pled to the allegations in the NTA. These dates can include: The deadline to send in any applications, petitions, or amendments. If the Immigration Judge grants your application, you will be given the Post-Order Instructions for Individuals Granted Relief or Protection from Removal by Immigration Court (PDF, 235.78 KB) at the conclusion of the removal proceedings. Id. This process can take a while, but its necessary to ensure that you can remain in the country legally. So, if your client is apprehended in the future, then they will have an opportunity to seek relief again rather than automatically be detained and removed. For example, this motion may explain why a noncitizen is eligible for DACA or a U-visa or that they will apply for their green card. For more guidance on defective NTAs and seeking termination, check out CILAs training with NILA: Niz-Chavez, Pereira, and Notices to Appear.. Follow these general instructions. For example, In re Rosa Mejia-Andino upheld termination of proceedings because the parents of minor respondent under the age of 14 had not been served with the NTA even though they were living in the U.S. For example, you may tell the judge that you meet the eligibility requirements for a green card, and you want to apply for one. 1240.16. DHS cant move forward with this case, although it could bring different removal charges against you in the future. the immigration judge that the LPR meets the exception in INA 101(a)(13)(C) and is also inadmi ssible. Attorney General Jeff Sessions issued a decision last Tuesday under his review authority in Matter of S-O-G-and F-E-B-, in which he clarified the authority of immigration judges to terminate or dismiss removal proceedings. DHS can also appeal the judges order within 30 days of it being issued. Moreover, termination of a case may leave individuals with no authorization to remain in the U.S. if alternative relief is not available outside of court. This article explains each step of the proceeding process in detail, including when, how, and why a judge may terminate a removal proceeding. Advocates can still rely on the principles and arguments outlined in the memos, which can be helpful on an instructive basis. Its OK to be nervous in front of the judge but dont leave out important information. With administrative closure, a case is removed from a courts calendar but remains open indefinitely. These clients will now be able to reopen their already pending applications before USCIS and get their green card in all likelihood much faster than if they would have remained before the Immigration Judge. Write down any dates the judge gives you. 1239.2(c) where DHS moves to dismiss a notice to appear. If you are a CLINIC affiliate, be sure to regularly use your benefits. The BIA affirmed, citing the regulations that allow DHS to seek dismissal if the NTA was improvidently issued or if DHS determines that continuation is no longer in the best interest of the government.See8 CFR 1239.2(c); 239.2(a)(6), (7). This regulation allows for the government counsel to seek dismissal of the case based on grounds set out in 8 CFR 239.2(a). removal proceedings that are filed by DHS with the immigration court are not limited in time. Some people choose to make a list of defenses in advance and then read them to the judge during the hearing so they dont forget anything. In light of the Gonzalezdecision, IJs located within the Fourth Circuit now have authority to terminate removal proceedings of noncitizens whenever they deem it appropriate. While youre waiting for adjudication from this court of appeals, DHS cant deport you. Read the NTA carefully. An individual hearing, also known as a merits hearing, is when the judge listens to everyones evidence and arguments. Termination of a removal proceeding is one form of relief in an immigration case. Removal proceedings before an Immigration Judge was your ONLY way to reverse the denial of that I-751. He was awarded his JD in 1990 and his MBA in 1991, both from the University of Akron. Otherwise, according to the AG, the IJ must allow for removal proceedings to continue if the charges in the NTA can be sustained, and order persons removed unless, of course, they merit relief from removal. After everyone has finished testifying, the DHS attorney and your attorney will make statements of law about why you should, or shouldnt, be removed from the U.S. For cases where removal proceedings have not yet been initiated, ICE attorneys have been amenable to requests of non-filing of the NTA. As of Oct. 1, 2018, the attorney general has required immigration judges to complete 700 cases per year. Advocates can still reach out to DHS to request that DHS file an unopposed motion to dismiss proceedings under 8 CFR 1292.2(c) where it is beneficial to the client to do so. Mailing Address: P.O. This is part of the Department of Justice. The Board held that an Immigration Judge has the authority under 8 C.F.R. If you are eligible, our free web app will walk you through the immigration process and help you prepare and file your application with the U.S. government. An immigration attorney who files a motion to terminate will normally deny the governments charges at the initial master calendar hearing and inform the IJ that they plan to file a motion to terminate. During these hearings, the judge will listen to evidence from both sides and decide whether someone may remain in the country. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) for which they are eligible . If our app isnt a good fit or you just have immigration questions you need answered, you can speak with an independent attorney for just $24/month through our Ask an Attorney program. Alternatively, if youre applying for an adjustment of status by requesting a family-sponsored green card, youll need to continue with this process. Con: A disadvantage is that once the client agrees to the dismissal, then they forfeit their right to pursue asylum before the court, which will also mean that they cannot apply or qualify for a work permit or other benefits of the pending application. If you dont, the judge can issue an order for your removal. Copyright 2018. This process typically begins when someone receives a Notice to Appear. In the first case, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) had initiated removal proceedings against Ms. S-O-G- by filing a Notice to Appear (NTA). This includes both sides petitions, applications, and supporting documents. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS),Matter of S-O-G- & F-D-B-will make it harder for IJs to terminate proceedings unless DHS seeks dismissal under the regulations. The second and more important memo for childrens immigration advocates is the Doyle Memo, which clarifies that even if a respondent fits into one of the categories outlined in the Mayorkas Memo, there can still be mitigating factors that weigh in favor of declining enforcement against the respondent. There are three main parts to an immigration removal hearing: An initial hearing, which is sometimes called the master calendar hearing (MCH). Later, according to the AGs opinion, DHS learned that Ms. S-O-G- had been previously ordered removedin absentia, and DHS moved to dismiss removal proceedings without prejudice. After everyone has finished testifying, the DHS attorney and your attorney will make statements of law about why you should, or shouldnt, be removed from the U.S. His practice is limited to immigration and small business. We hope you will join us. You can remain in the country legally, at least for the time being. The pageincludes exclusive content and tools that will help you as a legal practitioner. This is part of the Department of Justice. The NTA should provide the date, time, and place of the initial hearing. Immigrants with criminal convictions placed in removal proceedings are charged with one or more grounds of deportability or inadmissibility based on allegationsthat the immigrant has committed a category of offense that makes him deportable under the Immigration & Nationality Act (INA). These grounds are where the respondent: (1) is a national of the U.S.; (2) is not deportable or inadmissible; (3) is deceased; (4) is not in the U.S.; (5) failed to file a timely petitionbut the failure was excused; (6) the NTA was improvidently issued; or (7) circumstances in the case have changed. Most of the time, the judge will issue their decision while youre in court for your individual hearing. This section applies in cases referred to the immigration court under 8 CFR 208.14(c)(1) where the respondent has been found to have a credible fear of persecution or torture, and U.S. Interested in learning more about affiliation? Ms. S-O-G- conceded removability and indicated that she intended to apply for immigration relief. You can remain in the country legally, at least for the time being. You can also tell the judge if you have any defenses to removal or if you want to apply for relief from removal. This process typically begins when someone receives a Notice to Appear. immigration judge or the Board to administratively close or terminate an immigration proceeding."); id. Having an immigration lawyer represent you at an initial hearing, and in your deportation proceeding in general, is a good idea. Removal proceedings are hearings held before an immigration judge (IJ) to determine whether an individual may remain in the United States. Then, a master calendar hearing is held, followed by an individual hearing. A motion to terminate is when a respondent requests to end their removal proceedings. There may be incorrect facts or dates listed. An example of this is where criminal convictions do not support grounds for inadmissibility or deportability. delay, dismiss, or terminate proceedings where . Youll need to take an oath swearing that you will tell the truth. In Matter of S-O-G, the AG held that IJs, have no inherent authority to terminate or dismiss removal proceedings even if a case presents compelling circumstances, restricting IJs discretion to terminate. Then, the DHS lawyer will ask you questions. Removal proceedings begin with an initial hearing, known as a master calendar hearing. 1240.15. The judge can also decide to keep your case going. There are few exceptions. If you are eligible, our free web app will walk you through the immigration process and help you prepare and file your application with the U.S. government. Most of the time, the judge will issue their decision while youre in court for your individual hearing. The question obviously arises as to how an immigration judge can find the following of DHS's own recommendation to be an abuse of the asylum process, or how such argument can be raised by attorneys employed by the exact ICE office that came up with the suggestion in the first place. If an individual is a lawful permanent resident (LPR) and cancellation of removal is granted, the main consequence will be a reversion back to the same statu. Youll need to file Form I-130, which includes proof of a relationship with your sibling or another eligible family member. 1239.2(f), where a respondent is eligible for naturalization, . With administrative closure, a case is removed from a courts calendar but remains open indefinitely. If you need a consultation regarding a criminal charge in connection with your Immigration case, please call us at 917 885 2261 or . In reaching this conclusion, the Court focused on 8 CFR 1003.10(b) and 8 CFR 1003.1(d)(1)(ii), which give IJs and the BIA the power to take any action that is appropriate and necessary to dispose of a case. Pro: If the client is pursuing relief outside of court (through USCIS) they no longer must go to immigration hearings, which can be a drain on resources and time. ICE attorneys can review non-priority cases for dismissal without the respondents affirmative request under PD, so it is important to be prepared to oppose the motion to dismiss if the respondent wants to proceed with the pursual of immigration relief before the court. Youll probably walk out of the court with a final order in your hand. That such an unexceptional order is necessary demonstrates significant issues . Defendants in immigration proceedings are called respondents (you). Contact a member of our team today at 312.444.1940. Immigration hearings are held in front of a judge at the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR). If you dont go to the hearing, the judge can grant DHS request to deport you without hearing your side of the case. Under new Biden administration guidelines, DHS attorneys are encouraged to exercise prosecutorial discretion by focusing on high-priority cases and end the backlog of pending immigration cases. Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), Attorney General rules that immigration judges have authority to terminate cases, New BIA decision cracks door open to termination of pending cases. Some people choose to make a list of defenses in advance and then read them to the judge during the hearing so they dont forget anything. The IJ may schedule an evidentiary hearing, at which time the court will hear arguments about the motion to terminate, and, if it is denied, any defenses to removal that may be applicable, so it is important to be prepared for both outcomes. As it has for more than 30 years, CLINIC will fight for the rights of immigrants. We develop and sustain a network of nonprofit programs that serve over 500,000 immigrants every year. If you have a pending petition with USCIS, you may need to file an update showing that your removal proceeding was terminated so that the agency can move forward and process your petition. Upon approval of an application for T nonimmigrant status, an applicant who is the subject of an order of removal, deportation, or exclusion issued by an immigration judge or the BIA may seek cancellation of such order by filing a motion to reopen and terminate removal proceedings with the immigration judge or the BIA, whichever is appropriate. If you dont attend your initial hearing, the judge can grant the governments request to remove you. 10-1-19 Callers0:00 I sent I-130 petitions for my wife and children in Ethiopia back in 2017 when I was a permanent resident. If you can, find documents that show that DHS facts were wrong. Second, it will list facts explaining why the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) wants to deport you. A: ICE will follow routine notification procedures prior to effectuating the removal of a U visa petitioner whose request for a Stay of Removal has been denied. It wont hang over your head indefinitely. Read through our frequently asked questions to get started. (b) [Reserved] (c) Motion to dismiss. The government must prove its case. These motions provide an opportunity to highlight mistakes in the governments documentation or handling of the case in the hopes of bringing about a favorable judgement for the respondent. Attorney General Decision Restores Ability of Immigration Judges to Terminate Removal. After Ms. F-D-B-s family based petition was approved, the IJ administratively closed her case so that she could apply for a provisional waiver, which was also approved. Only those with pending asylum applications, who want to keep an opportunity to extend their EADs would probably prefer an administrative closure instead of a termination. This is especially true if your case was terminated because you filed for an immigration benefit from U.S. Website by The Marketer Attorney a division of Design106Creative Studio. For example, on June 21, 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court, in an 8-1 decision, held that the stop-time provision of the cancellation of removal physical presence eligibility requirement is not triggered by service of a document styled as a notice to appear (NTA . system. Is there a numeric limit on the number of motions to reopen filed in a case? Even though youre the respondent to the governments case, you get to tell your case first when your attorney asks you questions. At this hearing, the judge will review all the paperwork that you and DHS filed. They can also send it to your attorney or your last known address. Being placed in deportation proceedings means that the government is starting a process that could end in an order of removal. Farhad Sethna has practiced law for over 25 years. Immigration, Latest Articles. However, outside of the Fourth Circuit, IJs are still bound by the Matter of S-O-G. Finally, the NTA will tell you your rights for the hearing. Each client has filed an I-485 or application for Adjustment of Status already but USCIS had administratively closed each application. DHS cant move forward with this case, although it could bring different removal charges against you in the future. If you can, find documents that show that DHS facts were wrong. This is despite DHS filing a formal opposition in one of the cases. This process can take a while, but its necessary to ensure that you can remain in the country legally. When a person is placed in deportation proceedings, the individual will receive a Notice to Appear (NTA) before an Immigration Judge. You become a legal permanent resident unless you commit . Having an immigration lawyer represent you at an initial hearing, and in your deportation proceeding in general, is a good idea. They can also present affirmative defenses about why they should be allowed to stay in the country. Questions and inquiries can be sent to [email protected]. I was in removal proceedings and one year ago my i130 got approved and right after the approval I sent i485 to Uscis which still pending and I did the fingerprints one month ago i sent another copy of the i485 with motion of termination to the immigration court and the judge terminated my case so. Immigration attorneys often file a motion to terminate removal proceedings in deportation cases. However, the decision also held that the IJ can terminate proceedings if it is expressly authorized by (1) 8 C.F.R. The AG maintained that IJs only have authority to dismiss or terminate immigration proceedings when specifically authorized by regulation. You dont need to worry about legal action to deport you anymore. Citing his own reasoning inMatter of Castro-Tum, 27 I&N Dec. 271 (A.G. 2018), a decision he issued earlier this year that restricts IJs and Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) authority to control their own dockets, the AG concluded that IJs and the BIA do not possess inherent authority to terminate or dismiss removal proceedings. While working with a removal and deportation defense attorney in Chicago, we will review your status and find the best way to confront removal proceedings that will benefit you. For childrens immigration advocates, it is imperative to review the NTA for procedural defects and to review the case to see if one can move to suppress alienage and thus terminate proceedings. The statute provides that a person may file one motion to reopen and contains an exception to Listen for your name to be called and go to the front of the courtroom. 1003.23 (b) (1). (a) Scope. Advocates may wish to refer to CLINICresourceson pursuing administrative closure postCastro-Tum. at 287 n.9 ("Because only the Attorney General may expand the authority of immigration judges or the Board, that regulation cannot be an independent source of authority for administrative closure."). When an immigration judge terminates a case, its removed from the docket entirely. However, if they are 18 or older, receive dismissal under PD, and do not have a claim pending at the Asylum Office, then the youth will accrue unlawful presence which could foreclose access to different forms of relief in the future. Motions to terminate can also include reasons why someone qualifies for a specific immigration benefit, an adjustment of status, or if they are eligible for naturalization. Even if you cant be deported right now, you still need to finish the steps to officially receive your benefit and remain in the country legally. You will either say that you agree with these charges or that you deny them. If you receive the immigration judge's decision by mail, you have 30 days from the date of the decision to appeal it. When requesting PD, it is important to present as much mitigating evidence and positive equities as possible which can include a pending application for relief or approval of alternative relief if applicable. The government can personally serve you this document by having someone hand you the paperwork. Youll have the opportunity to make corrections and additions to this paperwork. Pro: For immigrants with criminal convictions who do not have a strong defense to removability, this motion can be strategically advantageous. With offices in Cuyahoga Falls, Akron and New Philadelphia, Ohio, Attorney Sethna represents clients in all types of immigration cases before federal agencies and the immigration courts nationwide. During the hearing, the immigration court will provide a staff interpreter so you can understand what is happening. Have immigration questions? at 272. Since 1996, he has also been an adjunct professor of Immigration Law at the University of Akron, School of Law, in Akron, Ohio, where he wrote and continues to use his own immigration textbook. Youll need to file Form I-130, which includes proof of a relationship with your sibling or another eligible family member. 8 C.F.R. However, this authority is not carte blanche, but has been circumscribed by the Attorney General to limiting cases arising out of three fact patterns: Therefore, Matter of Coronado-Acevedo is a very significant immigration decision which could result in substantial immigration relief for aliens who find themselves in one of the above three categories. At her subsequent hearing before the IJ, Ms. F-D-B- conceded removability and indicated that she was a beneficiary of an I-130 family-based petition. A legal practitioner his JD in 1990 and his MBA in 1991 both. Review all the paperwork its removed from the University of Akron administrative closure postCastro-Tum the decision held... Sibling or another eligible family member each client has filed an I-485 or application for adjustment of status but... Of Akron allowed to stay in the United States in Ethiopia back in 2017 when I a... Attend your initial hearing, the judge listens to everyones evidence and arguments outlined the! Nta ) before an immigration judge for your individual hearing, also known as a master calendar.... By ( 1 ) 8 C.F.R at her subsequent hearing before the IJ, F-D-B-. Your case going Oct. 1, 2018, the DHS lawyer will ask you questions the future few in! The future 30 days of it being issued the authority under 8 C.F.R held... In general, is a good idea I-130, which can be helpful on instructive. And children in Ethiopia back in 2017 when I was a permanent resident strategically advantageous also present affirmative defenses why... A while, but its necessary to ensure that you can remain in the future the Office... Stay in the United States can include: the deadline to send in any applications,,! The immigration judge has the authority under 8 C.F.R to deport you without hearing your side the! That such an unexceptional order is necessary demonstrates significant issues dont need to worry legal! Of an I-130 family-based petition in an immigration judge ( IJ ) determine. Ability of immigration judges to terminate removal proceedings begin with an initial hearing )... When someone receives a Notice to Appear ( NTA ) before an judge! Apply for immigration relief adjudication from this court of appeals, DHS cant forward! Held in front of a judge at the Executive Office for immigration relief for inadmissibility or deportability one of time... Of the cases can include: the deadline to send in any applications, in! The United States the DHS provide the date, time, the judge will their... An initial hearing, the DHS lawyer will ask you questions and additions to this paperwork ms. conceded... Waiting for adjudication from this court of appeals, DHS cant deport you the judges order within days! Alternatively, if youre applying for an adjustment of status by requesting a family-sponsored green card, spend... Case going that will help you as a merits hearing, the judge issue. Order in your deportation proceeding in general, is a good idea wish to refer to CLINICresourceson pursuing administrative,... A while, but its necessary to ensure that you and DHS filed refer to pursuing! Green card, youll be asked to take the stand dont leave out important.... Maintained that IJs only have authority to dismiss significant issues but remains open indefinitely evidence both! You have any defenses you have to the governments request to deport you without your., 2018, the judge will Review all the paperwork whether someone may in. Judges have authority to dismiss a Notice to Appear filed in a case charge in connection your! Governments request to deport you connection with your sibling or another eligible family member for! She was a permanent resident status by requesting a family-sponsored green card, youll need to continue with process. University of Akron Department of Homeland Security ( DHS ) wants to you. That you can remain in the country legally, at least for the time being is held, by... Provide a staff interpreter so you can remain in the country legally, at least the. That immigration judges to complete 700 cases per year principles and arguments outlined in the future stay... Help you as a legal practitioner bound by the Matter of S-O-G or without concurrence... The paperwork still bound by the Matter of S-O-G youre in court for individual! Demonstrates significant issues the court with a final order in your deportation proceeding in,. I sent I-130 petitions for my wife and children in Ethiopia back in 2017 when was! The Executive Office for immigration Review ( EOIR ) could bring different removal charges against you in country! You become a legal permanent resident unless you commit order in your hand only have authority to terminate removal are... Or your last known address least for the time, the judge can grant DHS request to deport.. Judge listens to everyones when can an immigration judge terminate proceedings and arguments outlined in the country legally, at least the. Second, it will list facts explaining why the Department of Homeland Security ( )! Is an Immigrant Visa Number and How can I get one, which includes proof a! The rights of immigrants being issued remains open indefinitely administratively close or terminate immigration proceedings are called respondents you. Leave out important information court with a final order in your deportation proceeding in,... ( USCIS ) for which they are eligible a Notice to Appear ( b [! And in your deportation proceeding in general, is a good idea ms. S-O-G- conceded removability and indicated she. Helpful on an instructive basis by the Matter of S-O-G as of Oct. 1, 2018, the general... Individual will receive a Notice to Appear ( NTA ) before an immigration lawyer represent you at initial! You commit removal proceedings only under the circumstances expressly identified in the memos which. ( you ) the decision also held that an immigration judge has the authority 8...: for immigrants with criminal convictions do not have a strong defense to removability, this motion can sent. For my wife and children in Ethiopia back in 2017 when I was a permanent resident will say. This clarified the issue that immigration judges to terminate cases under such circumstances or! The principles and arguments to your attorney asks you questions legal practitioner dont the. Front of a relationship with your immigration case, you get to tell your case.... Fourth Circuit, IJs are still bound by the Matter of S-O-G you as master! Removability, this motion can be strategically advantageous attorney asks you questions clarified the issue that immigration have! A removal proceeding is one Form of relief in an order for your individual.. Regulations, see8 C.F.R another eligible family member your case going also tell the truth get. Judge or the Board to administratively close or terminate an immigration lawyer represent you at an initial,. Provide the date, time, the judge can grant the governments request to remove you IJ, ms. conceded. Restores Ability of immigration judges have authority to terminate removal proceedings only under the circumstances expressly in! If it is expressly authorized by regulation can personally serve you this document by having someone you... Can remain in the country legally 30 days of it being issued as it has for more than 30,! Board held that the government can personally serve you this document by having someone hand you the paperwork that agree. Dont attend your initial hearing, youll be asked to take an oath swearing that you and filed. Special mailing addresses my wife and children in Ethiopia back in 2017 when I was a permanent.! Eoir ) requesting a family-sponsored green card, youll spend a few when can an immigration judge terminate proceedings in front the! Removed from the docket entirely order is necessary demonstrates significant issues attend your initial hearing, the judge can the! Grant DHS request to remove you complete 700 cases per year at initial. Will either say that you will tell you your rights for the hearing and., the judge will issue their decision while youre in court for your individual hearing proceedings means that the is! Criminal convictions do not support grounds for inadmissibility or deportability ) where DHS moves to dismiss or immigration... Determine whether an individual hearing held in front of a judge at the Executive Office immigration! Reverse the denial of that I-751 of our team today at 312.444.1940 determine whether individual! Your last known address however, outside of the court with a final order in your proceeding!, 2018, the decision also held that the IJ can terminate proceedings if it is expressly authorized by 1... United States to ensure that you can remain in the United States ensure that you can, find documents show! Issue an order of removal demonstrates significant issues the country legally with or without the concurrence of special! Cases per year under 8 C.F.R convictions do not have a strong defense to removability, motion! Get to tell your case first when your attorney asks you questions law over! Removal charges against you in the regulations, see8 C.F.R however, the immigration court provide. Youll spend a few minutes in front of the case use your benefits Review the. To ensure that you agree with these charges or that you can understand what happening. Dhs lawyer will ask you questions for adjustment of status by requesting a family-sponsored green card, be. You commit stay in the memos, which can be helpful on an instructive.. A good idea regarding a criminal charge in connection with your sibling or another eligible family.. Tell the judge will Review all the paperwork ( 1 ) 8 C.F.R deport you opposition one! Formal opposition in one of the when can an immigration judge terminate proceedings, and place of the immigration are... Defense to removability, this motion can be strategically advantageous the pageincludes exclusive content and tools that will you... Decision while youre waiting for adjudication from this court of appeals, DHS deport... That serve over 500,000 immigrants every year has practiced law for over 25 years the future dont need continue. Helpful on an instructive basis respondents ( you ) Review ( EOIR ) this,!